Joe Pennacchio

Dennis Shulman in Denver last month.: Politicker photo 

They say there are about two or three enduring storylines in world literature, and over the last year there have proved to be two or three storylines in New Jersey politics..

In the U.S. Rep. Scott Garrett/Dennis Shulman Fifth Congressional District contest, the Shulman campaign argues that it’s the Ellen Karcher story all over again, with Garrett receiving a $41,000 tax break on a piece of land that yields approximately $700 per year in income.

In a television ad that went up today on Channel 5 in the district, Shulman charges that by enjoying the tax loophole, Garrett proves he is just another "corrupt politician."

State Sen. Joe Pennacchio gave up his delegate slot to stay in New Jersey for Labor Day weekend
BLOOMINGTON, Minn. While New Jersey Republicans gather for their convention, one person who’s staying home is state Sen. Joe Pennacchio, who was supposed to be a delegate.

Speaking to PolitickerNJ two weeks ago, Pennacchio (R-Montville) said he wouldn’t be attending for a number of reasons. For one, he decided after his U.S. Senate primary campaign to spend more time with his family. He also wants to spend more time focusing on his legislative career and his dental practice. But there’s something else too.

“To be honest with you, I didn’t want to party with the party leaders. The leaders everyone was talking about in my campaign,” said Pennacchio, whose delegate spot has been replaced by former Morris County Freeholder John Inglesino. “I have an indifference towards them as much as they have an indifference towards me.”

State Sen. Joseph Pennacchio lost his bid for the GOP U.S. Senate nomination
While dozens of candidates were making last minute appeals on primary day, Republican Senate candidate Joe Pennacchio spent the afternoon working on dental fillings and root canals. The next day, about 12 hours after congratulating rival Dick Zimmer on his victory, Pennacchio was at his Mount Arlington dental practice again, engaging in his pre and post-election routine: going to work.

“I make a habit of working my regular job on election day and the next morning,” he said. “It grounds me. It tells me who I am, gets me back with the people and in the mix.”

Pennacchio, a conservative, lost to the more moderate Zimmer, 46% to 40%, with Murray Sabrin, a finance professor at Ramapo College, taking 14% of the vote. But despite a respectable showing, Pennacchio was true to the persona he cultivated during the campaign, exemplified by his “Jersey Joe” moniker and the slogan that accompanied it: “He’s one of us!”

Sabrin for Senate spokesman George Ajjan won 29% of the vote against Rep. Bill Pascrell in 2004
If Murray Sabrin’spress releases from the primary campaign were to be taken literally, the New Jersey political scene would have been even more of a Bizarro World than it already is.

Republican Senate nominee Dick Zimmer would have been under federal investigation. Sabrin would have been endorsed by Gannett, or rather, the corpse of newspaper mogul Frank Gannet. Joe Pennacchio would have been a fascist. Tom Wilson would have resigned in disgrace from his post as Republican State Chairman. Chris Christie would not be the favorite potential GOP candidate for Governor next year. And Sabrin, who ultimately got 14% of the vote on primary day, would have been the clear frontrunner throughout the Republican Senate race and would have won every debate he participated in.

“Throughout this campaign we employed a creative strategy to try to cut through in a race where the press was paying very little attention to Murray Sabrin,” said George Ajjan, a former Republican kamikaze congressional candidate and frequent Republican pundit/blogger who worked as Sabrin’s communications director.

Ajjan was the operative who devised Sabrin’s unorthodox communications strategy that was at times clever and funny – like the time that Sabrin managed to get a blog entry on the Wall Street Journal’s Web site for letting $20,000 in campaign contributions ride in a 20-1 shot in the Kentucky Derby – but also earned ridicule from members of the Republican political establishment who bore the brunt of many of Sabrin’s press releases.

Ajjan won’t call his communications strategy misleading. He prefers the term “creative,” and notes that the press releases went out to the press and political insiders, as opposed to the general public, which saw a polished, mild-mannered candidate with a good grasp of economic issues.

MORRISTOWN -- Two and a half hours after the polls closed, state Senator Joe Pennacchio (R-Morris) conceded to challenger former U.S. Representative Dick Zimmer for the GOP nomination for U.S. Senate.

With 90 percent of districts reporting, Pennacchio netted 39 percent (64,643 votes), seven points behind Zimmer.

"This is a very Norman Rockwell moment," said Pennacchio in his concession speech, mentioning that the experience brought a sense of "validation" that he, the son of immigrant parents, could be a viable contender for the U.S. Senate.

Former Rep. Dick Zimmer, right, won the Republican nomination for U.S. Senate, defeating Joe Pennachio and Murray Sabrin: Politicker PhotoPRINCETON - Former Congressman Dick Zimmer secured the Republican nomination for U.S. Senate tonight, defeating opponents state Sen. Joe Pennacchio and college professor Murray Sabrin.

"Two months ago, I never thought I'd be running for U.S. Senate let alone anything else," Zimmer said, flanked by party officials including state Sen. Bill Baroni and former U.S. Senate candidate Anne Estabrook, who dropped out of the primary contest due to health reasons.

Taking aim at his fall opponent, current U.S. Sen. Frank Lautenberg, Zimmmer said, "You cannot expect someone elected 26 years ago to be the agent of change that we need."

MORRISTOWN -- With almost 75 percent of the vote tallied in Morris County, state Senator Joe Pennacchio holds a 21 point lead over challenger former U.S. Representative Dick Zimmer in the Republican U.S. Senate primary.

Pennacchio nabbed over 55 percent (8,321 votes) of the northern Jersey district, with Zimmer mustering 36.51 percent (5,486 votes). Economist Murray Sabin has 7.93 percent (1,192 votes).

The Pennacchio campaign considered Morris County a stronghold area as he represents portions of the county in the state Senate.

Update: Dick Zimmer has won the GOP U.S. Senate primaryPRINCETON -- With preliminary results pouring into the headquarters of Republican U.S. Senate candidate Dick Zimmer this evening, it looks as though Zimmer, a late entry into the contest, has taken an early lead in Somerset and Hunterdon counties despite the party organizational lines there being awarded to state Sen. Joe Pennacchio.

"That's where he lives, people know them there," says spokesman Ken Kurson, "people that know Dick Zimmer, love Dick Zimmer."

With 62% of the vote reported, Zimmer a resident of Delaware Township in Hunterdon County currently leads Pennacchio nearly two-to-one, 58-30%.

Can’t wait until tomorrow night to see who wins the major U.S. Senate and Congressional primary contests?

Below are some predictions from pollsters, political science professors and observers who track Garden State politics.

The observers were unanimous in their predictions for the Democratic Senate primary, foreseeing a relatively easy victory for incumbent Frank Lautenberg. On the Republican end, the outlook was not so clear cut, with observers split between state Sen. Joe Pennacchio and former Rep. Dick Zimmer. Ramapo College Finance Professor Murray Sabrin will have the support of presidential candidate Ron Paul’s fans, and could take some conservative voters away from Pennacchio.

In the heated Republican primary in the 7th congressional district, state Sen. Leonard Lance is the clear favorite. The 3rd district congressional primary, however, is a toss-up. In what has been perhaps the nastiest race of the election cycle, it was tough decide who had the edge between Medford Mayor Chris Myers and Ocean County Freeholder Jack Kelly.

These races will likely be determined by a very small number of voters. Even the most optimistic of outlooks puts voter turnout at approximately 30%, and most say they expect significantly less than that.

Maverick Murray Wins Debates Again