In a mayoral special election, Zimmer would start with strong, battle-tested base

In a mayoral special election, Zimmer would start with strong, battle-tested base

By Max Pizarro | July 30th, 2009 - 9:20pm
| More

Hoboken Council President Dawn Zimmer would become acting mayor in the event that Mayor Peter Cammarano resigns, and it does not appear, at least for the moment, that anyone's big enough to threaten her in the special election. 

Gov. Jon Corzine today said Cammarano will be gone tomorrow, but no one's yet heard that publicly from Cammarano.

If he steps down prior to Sept. 4th, the mile-square-city will hold a special on Nov. 3rd, the same day as the gubernatorial contest between Corzine and Republican challenger Chris Christie.

Most people assume Zimmer will run for mayor.

She was the top vote-getter in the May election, and in the runoff beat Cammarano on the machines only to lose by 161 votes after the Board of Elections factored in absentee ballots. Her supporters will be more revved up than ever with a sense of righteousness. Cammarano was already an opponent. Now, charged with allegedly taking cash bribes, he departs as an outright villain.

After Zimmer, the field gets fuzzier, if there even is a field.

The Council President built her eclectic base out of the mortar mix of good government grassroots activists, the youth, Kids First mothers past the baby buggy stage of life, and Hoboken newcomers.

That leaves over 50% of the city remaining for a challenger to mine votes: namely among the born and raised old Italian populations, and in the Housing Authority Hispanic sections of town; and among the more conservative financial sectors of the city, including any pro-development voters. 

Those are Zimmer's weakest areas, which Cammarano gobbled up in May and June elections without sizeable opposition.  

The trouble for a challenger - and this is what 2nd Ward Councilwoman Beth Mason discovered when she tried to run a fusion ticket  - is that it's very difficult to promise not to cut city jobs to the born and raised base, while simultaneously promising lower taxes to the yuppies. It's difficult for someone to articulate in slogans an anti-development platform while also being pro-development.

Cammarano managed to master a one-Hoboken mantra, but only with a long campaign runway, and some other skills. His critics would say they were skills that didn't necessarily lend themselves to good government.

In a special election like this, there's no 50% plus one rule. It's winner take all, same as it was in 1992 when reform candidate Bret Schundler became mayor of Jersey City with less than 20% of the vote.

That's good news for Zimmer, who right now owns 49% of the vote in Hoboken, although Mason backers argue that part of that support comes from the 2nd Ward councilwoman's runoff endorsement of Zimmer. 

After the Council President, there's no obvious threat, no one who jumps out to assume the role of counterpoint. There are plenty of probable spoilers. Sources say Mason may run again, but Zimmer already defeated Mason, and cornered the good government reform vote, in the process exposing Mason's vulnerabilities outside her own 2nd Ward. 

There are those who believe with the right cornerman, Mason could do significantly better.

"Beth Mason is very credible," said veteran Hudson County political consultant Paul Swibinski, who worked for Cammarano. "That's a woman who should have been elected mayor. I remember looking at polls back in December, which showed Cammarano at 3% and Mason at 27%. She ran the worst campaign ever - I've been around for 30 years - and she can't escape culpability for it, but I think things could be different with one person in charge."

There's also the potential, in a crowded field, for 3rd Ward Councilman Michael Russo to get in the contest, but his born and raised base could be chopped into pieces by perennial, can't-resist-a-run candidate Frank "Pupie" Raia.  

Assemblyman Ruben Ramos (D-Hoboken), a born and raised who served as a 4th Ward councilman before securing an at-large seat, is definitely staying out of a mayoral contest, according to sources.

"As Peter took the oath of office, I had this sinking feeling that i didn't have a Plan B," said Hoboken native Perry Belfiore. "For a while now I've felt that I was about to surrender to someone who was not born and raised. That turned out to be Peter. I felt comfortable. But now it's a South African situation where the disorganized majority will be ruled by an organized minority."

Among reformers, At-Large Councilman Ravi Bhalla, the high vote-getter in last May's local elections and a Zimmer ally, won't run. He's loyal to Zimmer.

"I'm backing Council President Zimmer for Mayor," Bhalla told PolitickerNJ.com tonight.

Swibinski said several people have encouraged former Council candidate (and Cammarano ally) Mike Novak to run.

An environmental engineer who can raise money, Novak was going to run for mayor with the slogan, "He's going to remediate Hoboken," and he could try to sell himself as the numbers cruncher Hoboken needs to cut taxes and reduce the size of government.

Of course, there's the Cammarano association problem, although Swibinski thinks Novak's still sufficiently a newcomer not to be damaged.

"Mike was going to run for mayor and I talked him out of it, and convinced him to run with Pete Cammarano - and he is still talking to me," said Swibinski. "He's a very appealing candidate, but I don't think he'll run. Mike and I have talked about it and my sense is he's not going to do it." 

The Schundler story may fill Republicans with a sense of history now as they seek targets of opportunity for Christie in a gubernatorial election year. However, their efforts to recruit a Wall Street outsider to run for mayor on the Christie ticket could simply imperil their gubernatorial candidate's chances of pilfering votes in heavily Democratic Hoboken.

Zimmer accomplished what she did - nearly beating Cammarano - in the face of the Democratic Party machine.

An independent Dem, she's no big Corzine fan. But if Christie or his Republican allies actively backed a candidate against her, Zimmer and company could be antagonized straight into the Corzine camp. Even with the specter of Cammarano, the last thing the GOP wants is to give Zimmer's grassroots minions an invitation to attach themselves completely to the machine in this Democratic Party stronghold. However hampered, it's still Hoboken. If they leave her alone, some of the independent streak in her could wear off in Christie's direction.

That's some heavy lifting there...

Very interesting article and thorough but you don't say much about some of the other folks who might throw their hat in the ring or perhaps you don't think that craven desire for power alone is sufficient.

Political consultant Paul Swibinski however has it all wrong. Many residents were eager to embrace Mason's years of efforts with support in the mayoral election. Whoever influenced and advised her leading into the election destroyed it all. It wasn't her campaign, it was who she became.

Ask people who had backed her for years. They all will repeat the same issues, the "develop or die" comment, the capitulation on need testing re: pilot consideration at Church Towers, the embrace of the very people whose methods she claimed to oppose in building her public career.

Mr. Swibinski suggests it would be different if her campaign is managed through one person. One imagines that person he believes it should be is Paul Swibinski.

Just don't see how Beth Mason can undo all that damage. She's a very well respected figure but people adopted Zimmer and now it's her chance to bring Hoboken into the 21st century of decent governance.

As for the election, with the FBI's revealing information on the true Cammarano, is there any doubt that he rigged the absentee ballots for all they were worth to get into the job?

Wake-Up Call

Morning News Digest: February 9, 2010

Garden State Equality fires new broadside at Dems Smarting over the state Senate's refusal to pass marriage equality and disillusioned at the moment with the Democratic Party majority, Garden State Equality’s 85-member Board of Directors unanimously decided against giving financial contributions to political parties and their affiliated committees. ...

Wally Edge

As the new administration looks to reorganize the embattled Passaic Valley Sewerage Authority (PVSA), watch for at least two part-time $53,420-a-year lawyers to be on the termination short list: James Piro, a former Essex County GOP Chairman and...
The brother of U.S. Rep. Frank Pallone has announced his candidacy for the Long Branch City Council.  John Pallone, who served as a Councilman from 1990 to 1994, said today that he would run with David Brown, the former Roselle Business...
A handwritten note left behind during a Senate Budget and Appropriations Committee meeting indicates that Senate Majority Leader Barbara Buono (D-Metuchen) would support a plan to require all current public employees to contribute at least 1.5% of...
As New Jersey braces for another snowstorm, noteworthy is Hamilton Mayor John Bencivengo’s website, where residents can use “Snow Plow Sal” to monitor the movements of snow plows to determine when their street will be plowed.  Hamilton also has...
Just before leaving the Senate Presidency, Richard Codey (D-Roseland) appointed Orange Mayor Eldridge Hawkins to the Congressional Redistricting Commission.  Now his successor, Stephen Sweeney (D-West Deptford) is considering making his own...

Contributors

Everybody needs to start a new job with a list of priorities and Chris Christie is no exception. There might be a thousand things that need to get done... more »
A new Governor and Legislature offer the perfect opportunity to re-think the Trenton status quo and for experienced observers and practitioners to offer their best ideas on improving the... more »
 I grew up in a neighborhood in Newark, New Jersey where gambling was part of every day life.  Many of my relatives gambled.  The guys gambled on games, and... more »
Due to a highly inappropriate breach of etiquette by President Barack Obama in his State of the Union Address, the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in the Citizens United... more »
When life is bad---natural disasters, families losing homes or jobs, an attack on our country, health crises--people come together and do things that are inspiringly good.  After the... more »
Our new Governor suffers from no lack of advice.  Much of it, contained in the transition reports, deserves prompt attention.  Obviously, economic prosperity benefits everyone, and – as... more »
The agenda has been ambitious.Jobs.  Homeland security.  Iraq.  Afghanistan.  Healthcare.  Energy.  Banking.   Taken together, the Obama Presidency has all the makings of a compelling story -- action, adventure, emotion,... more »
The new regime pushes the only conservative off the Budget Committee.   This is a direct result of pressure from a certain Republican County Chairperson who was hired by Garden... more »
Now that  the dust has finally settled after the grueling campaign for governor, there are a number of lessons that we can draw from this election. First and... more »
A  few years ago, my brother Paul gave me a birthday present of Tim Russert’s book, The Wisdom of Our Fathers. Great book. Read it cover to cover. Or skim... more »
New Jersey's spending and borrowing spree over the past three decades is coming home to roost.  State debt has increased 700% under both Republican and Democratic administrations, and spending... more »
On January 11th New Jersey’s 213th Legislature ended its session, followed the next day by the commencement of the 214th Legislature, with newly elected officials being sworn into office,... more »
On January 6, 2010, several newspapers published articles with titles like “no more aid for struggling cities”, “Christie will cut state aid” and the like; furthermore, in the body... more »
New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, you target teachers. That’s not a positive note to start your tenure. You forget that the Teachers’ Union makes decisions on its own, such... more »