A Senate race unfit to print

By Juan Melli | October 27th, 2008 - 8:52am
| More

"New Jersey voters deserved a better race this year than the nearly invisible contest between Senator Frank Lautenberg and Richard Zimmer, his Republican challenger," begins the New York Times' endorsement of U.S. Sen. Frank Lautenberg.

Although accurate, a generous interpretation of this seemingly hypocritical charge is that it is in fact a veiled criticism of their own paper's decision to ignore the U.S. Senate race in New Jersey. Not once has the Times written a story about the general election contest between Frank Lautenberg and Dick Zimmer. (By comparison, Cynthia Burton at the Philadelphia Inquirer has written 11 pieces on the race.)

To add insult to injury, Zimmer told PolitickerNJ: "One of the editors of the New York Times who interviewed me for their editorial thought I was still a member of Congress."

It wasn't always this bad. The New York Times wrote about 70 stories -- mostly by long-time Trenton reporter David Chen -- on the 2006 general election race between U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez and state Sen. Tom Kean, Jr. They even had a great blog providing daily coverage of the 2006 Newark mayoral race. Fifty years ago, when campaign season was considerably shorter, the Times printed more than 30 stories on the Senate contest between Harrison Williams and Robert Kean.

The Times also made endorsements in New Jersey's 3rd, 5th and 7th Congressional Districts. Although both the 3rd and 7th are widely considered to be more competitive, the paper never wrote about those races and only once covered the 5th in a mainly biographical piece on challenger Dennis Shulman. That's right -- a relatively long-shot Congressional bid got more coverage than the U.S. Senate race.

The New York Times had a strong tradition in New Jersey with journalistic giants like Joseph Sullivan, Ronald Sullivan, Iver Peterson and Maurice Carroll. There was a time -- and it wasn't very long ago -- when the paper played an influential role in New Jersey politics. Just seven years ago, it was David Halbfinger whose reporting helped take down then-Acting Gov. Donald DiFrancesco. But nobody reads the Times any more for its coverage of New Jersey -- they couldn't, even if they wanted to.

A changing media and economic environment has forced many papers to make cuts and prioritize their coverage, and the Times is no exception. Over the summer they pulled staff out of their Trenton and Newark bureaus. David Chen was promoted to cover New York City Hall, and no replacement was ever announced.

It's not fair to blame the editorial board for the decisions made by the paper's management, and they're free to endorse whichever candidates they please, but they could have avoided the hypocritical tone in their endorsement if they had checked their own paper to see how often they covered the race.

Perhaps because of their long history of covering New Jersey politics and only recent change in focus, it doesn't appear so out of place to see their editorial board offering recommendations on races their paper no longer covers. But geographic proximity alone does not qualify one as an expert on his neighbors. Even the Times rightfully mocked Sarah Palin for that suggestion. And so in the not-too-distant future, a New York Times endorsement of a New Jersey race may very well seem as misplaced as a Star Ledger editorial weighing in on the New York City mayoral election.

i miss

i miss david chen

Dick Zimmer has no one to blame but himself

Mr. Zimmer didn't want to be a U.S. Senator until after the filing deadline; the party leadership had to ask several people to run at the last minute - instead of backing an experienced and respectable candidate who was working for it. Lautenberg won the race in late April, when the party leadership bailed on the one guy who really wanted to win: Joe Pennacchio.

Running for statewide office

seems to a merit badge rather than an attempt by the GOP to win. Tom Wilson will screw up next year's election if the "official" candidate turns out to be another slotted prima donna.

I agree that Jersey Joe would have made a fight off it. His supporters had fire-in-the-belly. There would have been blue collar fund raisers that would have peaked local audiences besides the money raised.

Running for statewide office

burp

"squeezed" media coverage

When time permits, I try to read every columnist on politickernj; in terms of research (including his previous piece), measured, articulate responses, and level of thoughtfulness, Melli is writing some of the best columns on this site. I try to say that objectively, despite my agreement with his political ideology.

Perhaps one of the benefits, if there are any, of the Times (and the Inquirer) cutting back on N.J. coverage is that this means state papers, such as the Courier Post and the Bergen Record, may recoup some lost local subscribers and refocus their attention on state issues, including political races such as our senate and congressional ones. The endorsements for the house from the Inquirer and NY Times were rather brief and pithy in content; it was obvious that neither paper had a grasp of local issues in this race, though this may be one of the few times that the Times has endorsed in a South Jerey congressional race.

Chen is gone? That's not good for state journalism.

Of Course You're Right Juan.....But

Let's face it, there wasn't much news in this race.

Lautenberg had no need for any press, and Zimmer didn't say or do much that was newsworthy.

On the other hand, it is the job of the region's newspapers to actually cover a Senate race!

The Times (as you correctly point out) failed to do their job on this one....but I doubt it would have made any significant difference in the race.

From Frederick Douglass

If there is no struggle there is no progress......Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will.

Coverage of the non-race was pathetic.

How do you expect the media to take Dick Zimmer seriously when the Republicans nominate him in a last minute fit after the other last minute flops decided not to run?

The race has been a sleeper for months because there wasn't a legitimate Republican willing to step forward to take on the fossil.

Lautenberg is an embarassment. His own staffers know that. But the Republican Party is so pathetic it can seem to get out of it's own way.

How John McCain is not leading this state by 5-7 points at this juncture is just amazing to me. The Bergen County Republicans don't even look like their going to win a freeholder seat despite the Ferriero/Oury scandals.

If they don't win at least one freeholder seat, they'll never win. They should just fold-up the proverbial political tent.

Vote Column "A" - All the way!

I made a fau paux yesterday

I said "Zick Dimmer"

Wake-Up Call

Morning News Digest: February 9, 2010

Garden State Equality fires new broadside at Dems Smarting over the state Senate's refusal to pass marriage equality and disillusioned at the moment with the Democratic Party majority, Garden State Equality’s 85-member Board of Directors unanimously decided against giving financial contributions to political parties and their affiliated committees. ...

Wally Edge

Just before leaving the Senate Presidency, Richard Codey (D-Roseland) appointed Orange Mayor Eldridge Hawkins to the Congressional Redistricting Commission.  Now his successor, Stephen Sweeney (D-West Deptford) is considering making his own...
Mark Anton, the Chairman of the Suburban Propane Gas Corporation, was a half-term Republican from Essex County who was elected in a 1953 special election after Alfred Clapp, who had mounted an unsuccessful campaign for the GOP gubernatorial election...
Assemblyman Herbert Conaway (D-Delanco) has dropped his bid for Burlington County Democratic Chairman, notifying party leaders by letter this weekend.  That leaves Gary Haman as the leading candidate to replace Alice Furia, who took over last...
New Jersey Sports and Exposition Authority President Dennis Robinson may be the new Bryan Christiansen, the embattled Passaic Valley Sewerage Authority (PVSC) Executive Director.  Robinson is using public funds to pay a politically connected...
The 2012 New Jersey presidential primary is scheduled for two years from today, and so far there has been no serious talk of changing the 2007 law that moved the 2008 primary from June to February in an effort to make the state more relevant in the...

Contributors

Everybody needs to start a new job with a list of priorities and Chris Christie is no exception. There might be a thousand things that need to get done... more »
A new Governor and Legislature offer the perfect opportunity to re-think the Trenton status quo and for experienced observers and practitioners to offer their best ideas on improving the... more »
 I grew up in a neighborhood in Newark, New Jersey where gambling was part of every day life.  Many of my relatives gambled.  The guys gambled on games, and... more »
Due to a highly inappropriate breach of etiquette by President Barack Obama in his State of the Union Address, the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in the Citizens United... more »
When life is bad---natural disasters, families losing homes or jobs, an attack on our country, health crises--people come together and do things that are inspiringly good.  After the... more »
Our new Governor suffers from no lack of advice.  Much of it, contained in the transition reports, deserves prompt attention.  Obviously, economic prosperity benefits everyone, and – as... more »
The agenda has been ambitious.Jobs.  Homeland security.  Iraq.  Afghanistan.  Healthcare.  Energy.  Banking.   Taken together, the Obama Presidency has all the makings of a compelling story -- action, adventure, emotion,... more »
The new regime pushes the only conservative off the Budget Committee.   This is a direct result of pressure from a certain Republican County Chairperson who was hired by Garden... more »
Now that  the dust has finally settled after the grueling campaign for governor, there are a number of lessons that we can draw from this election. First and... more »
A  few years ago, my brother Paul gave me a birthday present of Tim Russert’s book, The Wisdom of Our Fathers. Great book. Read it cover to cover. Or skim... more »
New Jersey's spending and borrowing spree over the past three decades is coming home to roost.  State debt has increased 700% under both Republican and Democratic administrations, and spending... more »
On January 11th New Jersey’s 213th Legislature ended its session, followed the next day by the commencement of the 214th Legislature, with newly elected officials being sworn into office,... more »
On January 6, 2010, several newspapers published articles with titles like “no more aid for struggling cities”, “Christie will cut state aid” and the like; furthermore, in the body... more »
New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, you target teachers. That’s not a positive note to start your tenure. You forget that the Teachers’ Union makes decisions on its own, such... more »