By Donald Scarinci | December 6th, 2012 - 3:38pm
| More

WAIT…just when you thought the legal debate over the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act AKA/ “Obama Care” was over, the Supreme Court said, “Not so fast!”

The United States Supreme Court ordered the Fourth Circuit Court to reconsider the challenges raised in Liberty University v. Geithner, one of many cases still working their way through the federal courts.  There are other cases in the courts as well which I discuss in the Constitutional Law Reporter.

When the Supreme Court upheld the sweeping health care reform law in June, it rejected all other pending appeals. However, Liberty University subsequently renewed its lawsuit this summer, arguing that it contained unresolved claims that should be decided in light of the Supreme Court’s historic decision.

The Supreme Court agreed. It recently granted the university’s petition for writ of certiorari and vacated the lower court’s judgment. It ordered the case back to the Fourth Circuit for further consideration in light its June decision.

Liberty University, a Christian educational institute, challenges the individual and employer health insurance mandates under the PPACA, primarily on religious grounds. It argues that the PPACA, namely provisions regarding contraception and abortion, violates its rights to Free Exercise of Religion and Free Association, guaranteed under the First Amendment; its rights to Equal Protection under the Fifth Amendment; and the rights to be free from governmental violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, among other arguments.

A three-judge panel from the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals previously rejected the lawsuit as premature. The panel found that because the individual mandate is a tax (as the Supreme Court later found); the Anti-Injunction Act prohibits the plaintiffs from challenging the mandate until the “tax” is collected in 2014.

The Fourth Circuit will now have to reconsider all of the issues raised by Lynn University anew. Once it renders a decision, the next stop for the case will likely be the U.S. Supreme Court.


Donald Scarinci is a managing partner at Lyndhurst, N.J. based law firm Scarinci Hollenbeck.  He is also the editor of the Constitutional Law Reporter and Government and Law blogs.

 

Wake-Up Call

Morning Digest: April 17, 2014

Bergen Dems demand Donovan cancel fundraiser with Christie after unlimited contributions commentsHACKENSACK - Bergen County Democratic Chairman Lou Stellato called on Bergen County Executive Kathleen Donovan to cancel a fundraiser scheduled for May 5 with Gov. Chris Christie after he made remarks on allowing unlimited campaign contributions to political...

Op-Ed

The future of NJ Politics should not be politicians investigating politicians

By JON BRAMNICK Voices around the country agree with our concern that "bipartisan committee led by John Wisniewski is partisan." Below are observers who agree Wisneiwski's committee is not bipartisan: Chuck Todd, NBC News: "Democrats made a mistake... Read More >

Contributors

(4-16-14) New Jersey Vote By Mail Law - The voter turnout for New Jersey’s November gubernatorial election was the lowest since the days of prohibition, coming... more »
When it comes to profiling Christie, facts are for wussies (4/10/14) - As the national media stories on our Guv pile up, expect more blunders about the Garden State.... more »
This week I begin a series called Dispatches from Somewhere Else. Based on my on-going experiences as an everyman in New Jersey politics, these Dispatches review the hollowness of... more »
Watching Governor Chris Christie's shocking BridgeGate implosion, it's easy to forget the time when he truly seemed unstoppable.  Blessed with incredible political gifts and a Jersey bluster to match,... more »

Quote of the Day

Quote of the day

“The new agenda is charter schools. It’s a profit-making business. $500 million will not be in our hands. The school board is an advisory board. We are not going to tell the governor to unleash the dollars. Don’t be fooled. It’s not abracadabra. It’s politics.” - Paterson Mayor Jeff Jones

- PolitickerNJ.com

Poll

Who does Alieta Eck want to win the CD12 Democratic Primary?:

Resources

Visit the PolitickerNJ.com/resources page for links to the best collection of information on New Jersey state government.

 

  • Polls
  • The best blogs
  • Columnists
  • State election results
  • Assembly election results
  • Local party websites
  • And more.

PolitickerNJ.com/resources