September 14, 2008 - 3:32pm
News

Sarah Palin, good ol' boy

She is reported to be smart, tough and a politically savvy working mother.

She has become the subject of celebrity-style media interest and of an astonishing barrage of stories and photos about her and her family -- some real and some fabricated -- winging across the internet.

Her arrival on the scene has triggered endless kitchen table discussions about parenting, work, teenage pregnancy and feminism. Her name has outpaced Google hits for "Paris Hilton" and "Michael Phelps."

Her speech to the Republican convention met with such breath less excitement from the mostly male delegates that I wondered if she had appeared, as depicted in that now-famously faked photo, in a flag bikini with a rifle rakishly held aloft.

The McCain team has worked tirelessly to project its vice presidential choice, Sarah Palin, as a "reformer" and a tough, whistle- blowing politician who took on the "old boys" in Alaska and won. But the reality is that Palin is herself completely entrenched in the "old boys network" it claims she fought.

Worse, Palin's policies, which are far to the right of the majority in this country, would not help women but would roll feminism backward and the "old boys" for ward.

Facing Barack Obama's popularity with women and blue-collar voters, the demographic that could likely decide this election, the McCain team needed a way to lift its campaign from its narcoleptic stupor. The surprising and risky choice of a nearly unknown Alaskan governor as McCain's running mate seemed like an ill-advised, ob vious attempt to capitalize on and lure discontented Hillary Clinton supporters who had fervently hoped to see a woman on the presidential ticket.

The notion that women who might have voted for Clinton would now vote for Palin (and McCain) simply because they share a gender seems preposterous. Yet one re cent ABC News-Washington Post poll suggests that on the heels of the Palin pick, white women have moved from backing Obama by eight points to supporting McCain by 12 points.

It's still unknown whether those poll numbers reflect a shift among women voters or whether they are a wild swing. What is becoming clearer, as Palin's past slowly surfaces, is that she is perfectly comfortable exchanging favors and playing by the "old boys club" rules -- seemingly with their playbook.

Palin has not been shy about accepting or giving political plums. In 2002, shortly after an unsuccessful run for lieutenant governor, she was appointed by former Gov. Frank Murkowski to chair the Alaska Oil and Gas Conservation Commission and given a six-figure salary despite the fact that she had no background in such issues.

After Palin unseated Murkowski as governor, she handed out the plums herself. One plum -- a paid position as director of the $35 billion Alaska Permanent Fund, which rebates oil royalties to residents -- went to Palin's close friend Debbie Richter, who also served as treasurer of Palin's gubernatorial campaign committee. Another went to Aryne Randall, branch manager of the Wells Fargo bank that gave the Palins and Richters loans for their properties. Palin's tendencies toward cronyism and a heavy-handed management style have pockmarked her political as cent, and she has left a string of questionable firings and resignations in her wake.

Once elected mayor of Wasilla in 1996, Palin fired the police chief, demanded the resignations of all other department heads, including the city planner and finance direc tor, and attempted to fire the city's librarian -- who refused to remove books from the town library -- re lenting only when the town op posed her action.

Local critics charge that Palin replaced the "old boys club" with a "new set of old boys," hiring inexperienced staff and a town administrator to do the work of running the small town while she still ac cepted her mayoral salary.

While governor, she fired the state's public safety commissioner, allegedly because he refused to dismiss her ex-brother-in-law, a state trooper engaged in a custody battle with Palin's sister. An investiga tion into "troopergate" continues. Last year, Palin abruptly fired her longtime aide and legislative direc tor, John Bitney, just weeks after her friend Scott Richter told her that Bitney was having an affair with Richter's now ex-wife, Debbie.

While there is still little known about Palin, we do know that McCain has selected a running mate who, as a potential leader of the Free World, holds positions on women's issues that are out of touch with the majority of voters. That's especially true of her pro-life stance, which would deny women abortions even in cases of rape and incest.

We know that the swirling accusations of abuse of power, cronyism and a legacy of firings have infected her political life. We also know that the "old boys' network" lets women play if they play by the rules, and Palin seems to have mastered them.

CARLA KATZ can be reached via email at carla.katz@politickernj.com.
Related topics: Sarah Palin

Comments

Fact Check


How can Sarah Palin be out of touch on the issue of abortion, she has faced the trials that the issue brings with a pregnant teenage daughter and herself being pregnant with a child with down's syndrome? She's obviously very much in touch on this issue, more than most people. Just because the latest talking point from the Obama campaign is to accuse McCain/Palin of being out of touch at every turn, it doesn't mean you have to use them when they obviously don't fit.

The independent non partisan group, factcheck.org, has this to say about the librarian situation, "She did not demand that books be banned from the Wasilla library. Some of the books on a widely circulated list were not even in print at the time."

http://www.factcheck.org/elections-2008/sliming_palin.html

You're using old recycled material from other bloggers.

By accusing a woman who's had to face the difficult realities of abortion unlike most as out of touch while accusing her of clear lies already debunked, Ms. Katz, you appear to be as out of touch in your career as a political "columnist" as you were as a union "leader". I wouldn't expect a response from you on this, but I would expect you to eagerly put out another column in a few weeks when the new talking points get in.

09/14/08 5:44 pm

Yawn


You mean a left wing, big labor boss who thinks the state gov should be bankrupted so her members can take larger swills from the public trough on the backs of the working families they claim to represent doesnt like Palin? Really? Wow...that's news.

Next...

09/14/08 5:55 pm

Carla beat the MSNBC to the ground!


A lot of work for the leftist media could be saved, if they only consulted with Ms. Katz. I mean to come up with this head line is sheer idiotism. Ms. Katz has put vicious and idiotic columnist from the New York Times to shame. “Palin replaced the "old boys club" with a "new set of old boys," does not even make logical sense, forget about its meaning.

09/14/08 9:44 pm

You are kidding


Carla, you are one to talk about others. Need I say more?

09/15/08 4:20 am

lipstick on a corrupt union thug ?


ooops you dont wear lipstick

09/15/08 8:22 am

Governor doing favors for close friends?


I'm sure Carla can agree that there is just about nothing that deserves jail more than a Governor doing favors for close friends.

Incidentally, who are those "blue collar workers" who love Obama? Are they in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Kentucky, Michigan or West Virginia?

They certainly aren't in New Jersey.

09/15/08 9:54 am

Should CHeck Carla's Email


Her boyfriend (sorry ex) probably wrote the article for her any way. He was the architect of the collective bargaining agreement where she screwed her own delegates. Nothing Ms. Katz says should be construed as original, her idea or factual.

This page should end her column.

09/15/08 12:54 pm

What Makes Katz a Political Columnist Anyway??


I mean seriously? She has carnal experience of course but she basically is a Union Leader who sold out the union for her own benefit and the benefit of the Governor then somehow avoids jail. Delivered the union vote to the Governor and avoids jail. Was voted out by the union and now she writes politcal columns??? God Bless America!!

09/15/08 12:57 pm

NextGenGOP


As a State worker, I am sick to death of being demonized as the cause of the state’s fiscal woes. The vast majority of my colleagues are dedicated professionals making far less than we could in the private sector because we are committed to public service and improving the health, education and circumstances of our neighbors. We’re working families too.

Not one of my college roommates makes less than six times my salary. I used to commiserate with one about our dysfunctional bosses. However, she was making a comfortable six figures (a lot 12 years ago) and literally millions in stock options. I was fighting for a printer.

I am regularly appalled at the bitter vacuous nastiness of some posters here. Didn’t your mothers teach you manners?

09/15/08 3:44 pm

What a Woman!!!!


Methinks that Carla wishes she could be half the woman that Sarah Palin is. Give it a rest, Carla. You couldn't even start to be a real feminist if you had three lifetimes.

09/15/08 5:27 pm

Palin, the horrible


That Sarah Palin would be one heartbeat away from the presidency, should anything happen to McCain (hypothetically, if he were, nightmare upon nightmare to win), should send tremors through any person, particularly if they aren't a fundamentalist right-wing ideologue, as she is. I don't care about her family issues, as seems to be the case with Katz's critique: I only care about her incredibly fringe views on abortion (even raped women must carry their pregnancy to term in Palin's world), on the Iraq War (a "task" from God), and a host of other issues (supports a constitutional amendment to ban gay marriage, for example).

That she is even considered some voice for the women's movement is degrading to the advances women have made in this country. Her view of government is patrilineal, her view of social rule, partiarchal.

The Palin selection marks a moment of truth for this country. That is, will voters decide to support this provincial, superficial image of Americana, illustrated by Palin? Or will real issues and real solutions, a la Obama and Biden, prevail instead?

09/15/08 9:53 pm

DumboCRAPS the Idiots


Who Am I?

I am under 45 years old,

I love the outdoors,

I hunt,

I am a Republican reformer,

I have taken on the Republican Party establishment,

I have 5 children.

I have a spot on the national ticket as Vice President with less than two years in a governor's office.

Did you guess?

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

I am Teddy Roosevelt in 1900

09/15/08 10:28 pm

Yo Reason


Get used to it. If you don't like it, why don't you take one of those private sector jobs paying six times your salary?

09/15/08 11:35 pm

Democarcy Dead in CWA 1040


I know this is off topic but I am sure Ms. Katz will allow me this freedom.

Democracy is based on the idea of freedom of choice. In this election season where so many important choices are being made in this country I have been kept updated by some friends who are in a battle to save democracy in their own Union.  Their fight is a fight that should never be occuring, but since it is " only" a fight that effects seven or eight thousand state workers it is ignored.

It is upsetting to me . It might be upsetting to some of you. Power indeed does seem to corrupt.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
RELEASE 9/15/08  COMMITTEE FOR FAIR ELECTION

CWA 1040 PRESIDENT CAROLYN WADE SCHEDULES HER " LEGITIMATE" SWEARING IN CEREMONY.

Taking a page from an anti-democratic Election manual, current CWA 1040 President Wade helped  guide her hand picked Election Committee into making the decision to throw out Reform Candidate Tom Bruno's nominating petitions on September 4, 2008. The petitions contained over 400 signatures from CWA 1040 members  who wanted an opportunity to participate in a fair and open election. The word was then put out that since there was no opposition there would be no election. This " No contest" election made Wade President of CWA 1040 for three more years. Members were not officially informed of  the news that nominating petitions had been disqualified. Most currently believe that Wade had no opposition.

The Reform Candidate Tom Bruno never received official written notice of  the Election Committee's decision  and then after asking and reminding the Committee that official Appeal paperwork must be sent immediately he has had to endure their refusal to follow even that simple rule. It has been 11 days and no appeal paperwork has been sent.

Current President Wade then scheduled her official swearing in ceremony for Monday October 6, 2008 at the opening of the CWA 1040 three day convention at the Taj Mahal in Atlantic City. This extravagant event, that costs the dues paying members over a quarter of a million dollars, will be promoted as a legitimate function of a " Democratic Union". To add to the deception  of democracy Wade has arranged to have representatives of the National CWA Union on hand to perform the swearing in ceremony.  

All of this " Democracy " continues while the State sends $250,000 in forced  collected Dues money, guaranteed by State Statute 34:13A - 5.5 ; 5.6, to this Union every 2 weeks.          

09/16/08 6:54 am

Blah Blah Blah


Someone wake me she stops spouting.

09/16/08 4:28 pm

Replies


NextGenGOP
I’m glad you or someone pulled your other post. I was going to thank you for so beautifully illustrating ‘appalling’ for me (to which for obvious other posters I must on occasion add ‘infantile’). Though I did very sincerely appreciate your ps laugh.

Just Me
Do you really think those incidental personal details have anything to do with one’s ability to govern? I am no student of Roosevelt, but I strongly suspect one might cite other, more substantive qualities and talents that better explain his success, ones I doubt Palin shares.

And Yo Mountaintop
Never mind.

I don’t expect there are many NYT readers or believers among the cantankerous conservatives here, but: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/14/us/politics/14palin.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq...

09/16/08 6:01 pm

Really?


Anyone else find it funny that a union boss who is tied to our corrupt Governor is telling us about cronyism?

09/16/08 9:27 pm

tReason


Are you posting on government time? Heres a fact when they shut state government down last year due to the corrupt and "too be indicted" fool of a governor...guess what...those of us "hard working" non-state employees didnt feel a "great loss of services"!

I have 3 family members who work for the state on NJ..every holdiay and funeral all I hear is how proud they are of how little work they do...and hear them complain about their 10 insurance co-pay..while they make over 80K a year for showing up a sitting at a desk..

I Cwhorezine was serious about something he would start by firing you!!!

09/16/08 9:58 pm

Definitions of prostitute


Definitions of prostitute -a woman who engages in sexual intercourse for money
sell one's body; exchange sex for money

Facts about Cwhorezine and Carls

1.he gave — and then forgave — a $470,000 mortgage

2. gave her $1.1 million for a condominium

3. gave her CWA bums and crooks a 13 percent raise over 4 years

She gave him sex!

So I guess the deinition is valid!

To other posters - Ill bet that tReason is really Carly postiing under an alias!!

09/16/08 10:05 pm

Carl Katz


Spreading her legs to advance the feminist cause.

09/17/08 2:03 pm

Atticus You are a pig. Just


Atticus
You are a pig. Just my opinion.

JustMe
Thank you for so economically illustrating both appalling and infantile for me.

Your definition of prostitute strikes me as a bit self-referential. Even if you haven’t had occasion to partake of their services, I expect you know there are male prostitutes too

Why would you presume I am at work at 6pm on any given day? Maybe I’m home fighting the laryngitis that’s going around, trying not to infect the offic. Maybe I work 7:30 to 5:00. Is anyone paying you to be doing something else when you’re posting in the middle of the morning?

I would suggest that the behavior of your family members is more a reflection on them than on me and my colleagues.

I also would suggest that your branding a large swath of the state workforce—of whom you could not possibly have first hand knowledge—as “bums and crooks” is more a reflection of some bitter prejudice on your part than of reality.

I’m a little ashamed of myself for engaging with you like this, so I’m going to stop now.

09/17/08 6:46 pm

tReason is Carla Katz


tReason is Carla Katz

09/18/08 6:52 am

Mrs. Palin "You're no Teddy Roosevelt"


Mrs. Palin is no Teddy Roosevelt. While you take a few "facts" and make a ludicrous comparison, Sarah Palin is not fit to shine the shoes Teddy Roosevelt.

He governed a State which had more people in 1900 than Alaska does now.

We was an established war hero from the Spanish-American war.

That's just two facts cutting the other way.

 

09/22/08 3:37 pm

Is Katz even around anymore?


Or did she find someone new to lay flat on her back for?

09/23/08 9:38 am

Oh my god! You people in


Oh my god! You people in media are such a bunch of liars and polarizers. It's not about left or right, ok? Both parties are bought and paid for by the private central bankers, the military industrial complex, and the multinational corporations. Barack Obama, Zbigniew Brezinski's puppet won't do a thing, and John "I know nothing about the econonmy" McCain won't do a thing.

The presidential candidates are mere puppets on a string, controlled and paid for. If they really wanted to "change" things like the messianic puppet Obama has the public "oohing and ahhing" over, either candidate would start with repealing the Federal Reserve Act of 1913, and bring back sound money printed by the people for the people, and not this debt based system that was created to enslave us in debt.

Both mainstream candidates messages are so nebulous. I can't believe so many Americans are still buying their crap. Change.....what are you specifically going to change?

09/24/08 10:49 am

Honestly, how do you live


Honestly, how do you live with yourself with the completely dishonest, and completely partisan, things you write. You are walking-talking points for the Democratic party. It is common practice to ask for those in key positions to give letters of resignation, and then those deemed loyal to the new direction of the newly-elected executive are kept, and those that are deemed to be against the newly elected executive and his/her policies are let go. She did not try to get rid of the librarian either. That is just silly. She inquired as to what the librarian would do if anyone or any group asked to ban a book, she was curious. Lastly, and maybe most importantly, you have again proven that the women's movement/women's liberation, or whatever you wish to call it, is only about liberal women and their belief in abortion rights. If Sarah Palin was pro-choice, all you liberals would be drooling over her. Instead of rejoicing that a women has reached a very high level, helping break that glass ceiling, you focus on abortion ... very sad.

09/27/08 6:58 pm

to the jewish Yenta Carla Katz-Clutz


Hey, what is it about Sarah Palin that you are most jealous about????
Her looks -compare to yours???-Absolutely!
A stunning hearthrob husband?-definately!
A classy elegant lady -not with a bushy pubic-like hair- Certainly!!!
And the brains- goes without saying!!!!!

10/04/08 4:17 pm

yes, change...


For the worse...
this man with community organizer experience of shaking down banks and bisinesess wil deliver change!
Isn't that a scary thought, he does have experience in corruption after all.
And can anyone imagine this racist Michell Obama who will be the president since she is running the show anyhow the first "LADY"
It isn't change-it is nightmare!!

10/04/08 4:27 pm

Democracy Dead in CWA 1040 Continues...


I know this if off the subject, but please humor me as I am new to this forum and have to comment about what firstamend07 wrote on 9/16/08. That posting had me cracking up as it is so true of CWA 1040 union. Unions as just as corrupt as the politics they support. Carolyn Wade needs to go! Give someone else a chance to do the job that she doesn't. I don't mean to lament about this, but we pay her 140,000+ yrly salary and the expenses of her "swearing in" today at the Taj @ 250,000.
I am, unfortunately, a member of this union and recently needed their support and all she could give me were semantics and empty rhetoric. Being a state employee, I have learned what happens when you don't play ball with them.

10/06/08 3:38 pm