High Court dismisses ethics grievance filed by Democratic state Senators from Essex
By Max Pizarro | January 9th, 2013 - 1:14pm
| More

Responding to a state Senate-requested advisory committee investigation into state Sen. Kevin O'Toole (R-40) spearheaded by senators Dick Codey, Ron Rice and Nia Gill, the New Jersey Supreme Court today denied there is any evidence of judicial and attorney misconduct in Essex County.

"The evidence of record indicates, clearly, that Senator O’Toole called Judge Costello on May 2, 2012 to discuss the reappointments of several Essex County Superior Court judges whose nominations for reappointment were in jeopardy," the Advisory Committee on Judicial Conduct report determined. "The mere fact that this telephone call occurred, however, is not itself evidence of judicial impropriety, but rather consistent with the past and present practice of the three branches of government in respect of judicial reappointments."

The advisory committee worked cooperatively with the Office of Attorney Ethics (OAE).

"Though it is undisputed that Senator O’Toole called Judge Costello concerning the reappointments of several Essex County Superior Court judges on May 2, 2012, there is no evidence to substantiate the allegation that during that conversation Senator O’Toole told Judge Costello the success of any jurist’s reappointment was dependent upon Senator Gill’s agreement to 'sign off' on a particular judicial nominee," the committee reported to the Supreme Court. "There is, likewise, no evidence to substantiate the allegation that Senator O’Toole directed Judge Costello to ask the judges awaiting nomination for reappointment to communicate with Senator Gill and advise her to 'sign off' on any judicial nominee."  

The committee said while it is undisputed that Judge Costello met with [the judges facing reappointment] and their presiding judges following her telephone conversation with Senator O’Toole on May 2, 2012, "there is no evidence to demonstrate that during those meetings she informed any one of them that their reappointments were dependent upon their ability to convince Senator Gill to 'sign off' on a particular judicial nominee.  Indeed, by all accounts no such conversation occurred.    

"Given the lack of any evidence to substantiate the allegations of judicial or attorney misconduct, the Committee has decided to dismiss this ethics grievance against the Respondents," the advisory committee concluded, which the court in turn accepted. 

Wake-Up Call

Morning Digest: August 22nd

Fight of the Week: Donovan v. Pascrell Fight of the Week Bergen County Executive Kathe Donovan v. U.S. Rep. Bill Pascrell (D-9) (Pizarro/PolitickerNJ) http://www.politickernj.com/79736/fight-week-donovan-v-pascrell     Paramus mayor's race: Candidates in closely-divided Bergen borough spar over taxes, towing issues PARAMUS - When voters go to the polls in November...

Op-Ed

White House’s Tuition Challenge Being Met in NJ

By MICHAEL W. KLEIN In his weekly radio address on August 16, President Obama challenged colleges “to do their part to bring down costs” and lighten the tuition burden on students.  The state colleges and universities in New Jersey have... Read More >

Contributors

(Asbury Park, NJ) -- There's a word for someone who says one thing and does another: hypocrite.  There's no shortage of 'em in Trenton -- from ... more »
(8-20-14) Can You Take the ‘Partisan’ out of ‘Partisan Politics’? - Redistricting will not take place for another seven years. Yet the debate has already... more »
    My Richard Nixon Ambivalence   Today is the fortieth anniversary of President Richard Nixon’s resignation address to the nation on August 8, 1974. At that time, I was ambivalent about... more »
 The following letter was sent today to Republican state legislators, county chairs, state committee members, and New Hampshire... more »

Quote of the Day

quote of the day

"But things get touchy between LaBarbiera and LoCicero when it comes to taxes, the bete noire of politics in the statewide election bellwether, Bergen County."

- PolitickerNJ

Poll

Is President Barack Obama too aloof from politics?:

Blogroll

Visit the PolitickerNJ.com/resources page for links to the best collection of information on New Jersey state government.

 

  • Polls
  • The best blogs
  • Columnists
  • State election results
  • Assembly election results
  • Local party websites
  • And more.

PolitickerNJ.com/resources