By Darryl R. Isherwood | November 11th, 2012 - 6:19pm
| More

Redistricting expert Tom Bonier, who acted as a consultant to the Democratic congressional reapportionment team last year,  has some harsh words for the map and the man who chose it.

In an Op-Ed submitted to PolitickerNJ,  Bonier, who has worked on redistricting campaigns throughout the country, savages the map ultimately chosen by tie-breaking member John Farmer Jr. as well as Farmer himself, saying the map is "partisan gerrymandered" and the man who chose it a "complete disaster.'  Farmer chose the map created by the Republican commission, which combined three North Jersey districts and all but guaranteed that the odd man out when the delegation shrank from 13 to 12 would be a Democrat.

"Despite Farmer’s impressive and distinguished success in virtually every other endeavor of public service, New Jerseyans can only hope that the "former" title attached to his position as a redistricting tiebreaker will remain forever permanent," Bonier wrote. "In other words, (Rutgers Law School) Dean Farmer should never, ever be permitted to be a neutral redistricting tiebreaker in any redistricting exercise going forward."

In the Op-Ed, sent four days after Election Day, Bonier decries the lack of competition fostered by the new map, which created an evenly split congressional delegation in the state.

"This week's results for New Jersey's 12 congressional districts - 11 landslide victories and one 8% margin - were predetermined months ago, the product of a colossal error by the reapportionment commission's Independent member," Bonier said.

According to Bonier, Farmer erred heavily by failing to institute a test to prevent gerrymandering, splitting apart towns that had been in the same district since the 1800's, failing to hold a public hearing on the map he supported, discriminating against North Jersey by determining that the lost district should come from the northern half of the state, and most egregiously - according to Bonier - not allowing voters to choose whether the lost delegation member should be a Republican or a Democrat.

Democrats had hoped that the map ultimately chosen by Farmer would allow for one so-called "fair fight" district where a Republican and Democrat would square off in an evenly partisan district.

Instead, Farmer chose the map submitted by Republicans that moved U.S. Rep. Steve Rothman from the heavily Democratic 9th District to the Republican 5th District, forcing Rothman to choose whether he would challenge 5th District Republican U.S. Rep. Scott Garrett or move to another district to challenge another sitting representative.

Ultimately, Rothman chose to challenge Democratic U.S. Rep. Bill Pascrell in the newly configured 9th.  Pascrell won the primary going away, leaving Rothman without a seat and the delegation evenly split at six Democrats and six Republicans.

Tuesday's election added insult to injury over Rothman's decision as unfunded challenger Adam Gussen lost to Garrett by just 13 points, sparking speculation that had Rothman chosen to run in the 5th he could have won.

Last week, a source close to Farmer said the elimination of a Democratic district was the result of demographics, not politics, because the districts that lost the most residents over the past decade were all represented by Democrats. In order to try to preserve seven seats, Democrats presented pretzeled districts that deviated from Farmer’s priorities of compactness and continuity, the source said.

Republicans also defended Tuesday's results, saying Dmeocrats had a legitimate chance in three districts that ultimately went for Republicans but chose weak candidates to run in those districts.

“It is hard to blame the map when our members of Congress were simply much better and stronger than the challengers the Democrats offered up,” said Mike DuHaime, who chaired the GOP redistricting team.  

Read Bonier's full Op-Ed here.

The Back Room

Sweeney goes on offense

Days after Jersey City Mayor (and 2017 gubernatorial hopeful) Steve Fulop declared his support and fundraising devotion to South Jersey Congressional candidate Bill Hughes, Senate President Steve Sweeney (D-3) see-sawed onto Fulop's turf with his own "I can find pockets of love in every part of this state including JC" statement.

Read More >

Wake-Up Call

Morning Digest: April 18, 2014

Fulop endorses Smith in Bayonne mayoral raceBAYONNE - Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop parachuted into the Bayonne mayoral race on Thursday night by endorsing incumbent Mayor Mark Smith."It is a pleasure to be with you here, Mark," said Fulop to a crowd of more than 125 supporters at a...

Op-Ed

How the City of Paterson became a city in crisis

By HAYTHAM YOUNES As the May 13th election for Paterson officials nears, I've noticed a lot of candidates running using slogans and empty promises as if they weren't around watching Paterson get to where it's at today. I think it's important that... Read More >

Contributors

(4-16-14) New Jersey Vote By Mail Law - The voter turnout for New Jersey’s November gubernatorial election was the lowest since the days of prohibition, coming... more »
When it comes to profiling Christie, facts are for wussies (4/10/14) - As the national media stories on our Guv pile up, expect more blunders about the Garden State.... more »
This week I begin a series called Dispatches from Somewhere Else. Based on my on-going experiences as an everyman in New Jersey politics, these Dispatches review the hollowness of... more »
Watching Governor Chris Christie's shocking BridgeGate implosion, it's easy to forget the time when he truly seemed unstoppable.  Blessed with incredible political gifts and a Jersey bluster to match,... more »

Quote of the Day

Quote of the day

"This is my first Mark Smith event. There have been a lot of changes in Hudson County over the last year and a half, and the most important change that has happened is that there really is unity. For the first time, we really are working together. Despite political differences. Mark and I have worked very hard to repair that. I'm really happy to be here in support of him, because I recognize that when you work together, politics becomes secondary and you really have time to focus on government, which is the most important thing." - Jersey City Mayor Steven Fulop

- PolitickerNJ.com

Poll

Was Frank X. Graves of Paterson New Jersey's best mayor?:

Resources

Visit the PolitickerNJ.com/resources page for links to the best collection of information on New Jersey state government.

 

  • Polls
  • The best blogs
  • Columnists
  • State election results
  • Assembly election results
  • Local party websites
  • And more.

PolitickerNJ.com/resources