Would have, could have, should have
By Max Pizarro | November 10th, 2012 - 7:53pm
| More

The irony of U.S. Rep. Scott Garrett (R-5) wriggling through Election Day without a serious challenge infuriated Democrats who had reason anew to bewail Steve Rothman’s decision to forego a general election showdown with Garrett.

Rather than run a general election campaign against the Sussex County Republican congressman in a GOP-edge district on paper, Rothman faced fellow Democrat Bill Pascrell, who retired him.

With Rothman sidelined out of political existence, Garrett on Tuesday night beat Teaneck Deputy Mayor Adam Gussen, 55-43%.

The irritable off-the-record reasoning by party members runs as follows: if Gussen came that close with no money and zero name ID, what might Rothman have been able to accomplish?

“Considering Obama’s margin of victory in New Jersey, maybe he could have done it,” said Patrick Murray, political scientist and pollster with Monmouth University.

Short of name ID and money comparable to an incumbent congressman, very few challengers would have had a shot, Murray added.

Throw in the wind assist – literally – of Hurricane Sandy underscoring the role of FEMA – and Rothman would have had the perfect platform to chop down Tea Party darling Garrett, the state’s lone movement conservative and only congressman to vote against more disaster relief.

“What a royal screw-up,” moaned one Democrat, speaking on condition of anonymity.

A familiar figure sat in the bar at the Heldrich Hotel Tuesday night, a few steps away from where Dean John Farmer picked the Republican Map that sliced Rorhtman’s district out from under him, and left him wavering between 9 and 5 before trying to tackle fellow Democrat Pascrell and instead getting kayoed himself.

Rothman Campaign strategist Paul Swibinski looked up from his drink.

“I don’t want to comment on that,” he told PolitickerNJ.com later when asked if Rothman would have been better off combating Garrett.  

During the brutal primary he waged against Pascrell, Rothman made it clear he didn't want a district that would have forced him to wrestle even more fitfully with Republicans. He had weathered Tea Party hazing during the heatlhcare debate and if he could help it he wanted less - not more - of such inter-party wrangling.

He likened Paterson to what Englewood was once, and told PolitickerNJ.com he wanted the challenge of confronting issues integral to urban Democratic life.

He didn't want to debate the 2nd Amendment with Sussex County and feel himself badgered righward in order to ensure general re-election victory every two years.

A schizophrenic district worried him.

He just didn't want it, he insisted. 

Wake-Up Call

Morning Digest: September 19th

NBC News: Federal charges ruled out for Christie in Bridgegate scandal NBC News tonight is reporting that federal investigators say after nine months of investigating Bridgegate there is 'no evidence" that Gov. Chris Christie had advance knowledge about any politically motivated scheme around the bridge lane closures at the...

Op-Ed

Legislation needed for publicly financed gubernatorial elections

By JEFF BRINDLE It is critical that the Legislature soon enact a pending bill that would ensure the state’s Gubernatorial Public Financing Program is available in the event of a special election for governor.  Not only is there no current legal... Read More >

Contributors

Sports and politics do mix: Welcome the next NFL Commissioner, Condi Rice          There are many sports fans who insist on believing that old bromide that sports and politics do... more »
(9-17-14) Viral Video Prompts Questionable NJ Municipal Ordinance -  Socrates said, “While I might disagree with what you say, I will defend to the death your right to say... more »
(Asbury Park, NJ) -- There's a word for someone who says one thing and does another: hypocrite.  There's no shortage of 'em in Trenton -- from ... more »
 The following letter was sent today to Republican state legislators, county chairs, state committee members, and New Hampshire... more »

Quote of the Day

quote of the day

“The fact is that they’ve been digging around for eight months now and have found absolutely nothing. Wrap up your work. Do your job." - Gov. Chris Christie

- PolitickerNJ

Poll

Should the Joint Legisaltive Committee investigating Bridgegate 'wrap it up?':

Blogroll

Visit the PolitickerNJ.com/resources page for links to the best collection of information on New Jersey state government.

 

  • Polls
  • The best blogs
  • Columnists
  • State election results
  • Assembly election results
  • Local party websites
  • And more.

PolitickerNJ.com/resources